HN Best Comments
前往频道在 Telegram
Comments from https://news.ycombinator.com/bestcomments Source code: https://github.com/border-radius/hn-best-comments
显示更多4 164
订阅者
无数据24 小时
-77 天
-1430 天
数据加载中...
吸引订阅者
九月 '26
九月 '26
+5
在3个频道中
八月 '26
+51
在9个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '26
+60
在10个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '26
+60
在6个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '26
+64
在5个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '26
+137
在9个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '26
+61
在9个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '26
+93
在4个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '26
+134
在8个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '25
+61
在6个频道中
Get PRO
十一月 '25
+126
在9个频道中
Get PRO
十月 '25
+227
在6个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '25
+429
在6个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '25
+1 000
在6个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '25
+249
在5个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '25
+45
在2个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '25
+48
在1个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '25
+25
在0个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '25
+23
在1个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '25
+604
在2个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '25
+303
在2个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '24
+25
在5个频道中
Get PRO
十一月 '24
+24
在2个频道中
Get PRO
十月 '24
+711
在3个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '24
+59
在4个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '24
+60
在3个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '24
+53
在1个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '24
+47
在3个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '24
+65
在7个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '24
+88
在2个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '24
+133
在4个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '24
+110
在4个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '24
+153
在8个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '23
+84
在2个频道中
Get PRO
十一月 '23
+130
在7个频道中
Get PRO
十月 '23
+122
在2个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '23
+58
在0个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '23
+107
在0个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '23
+67
在0个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '23
+78
在0个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '23
+334
在0个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '23
+326
在0个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '23
+51
在0个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '23
+36
在0个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '23
+294
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '22
+1 360
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十一月 '22
+71
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十月 '22
+36
在0个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '22
+55
在0个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '22
+43
在0个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '22
+89
在0个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '22
+203
在0个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '22
+42
在0个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '22
+23
在0个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '22
+23
在0个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '22
+38
在0个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '22
+47
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '21
+36
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十一月 '21
+75
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十月 '21
+44
在0个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '21
+14
在0个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '21
+46
在0个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '21
+71
在0个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '21
+172
在0个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '21
+287
在0个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '21
+15
在0个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '21
+16
在0个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '21
+28
在0个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '21
+34
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '20
+639
在0个频道中
| 日期 | 订阅者增长 | 提及 | 频道 | |
| 04 九月 | +2 | |||
| 03 九月 | +1 | |||
| 02 九月 | +1 | |||
| 01 九月 | +1 |
频道帖子
Re: Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
I think it's worth pointing out it is exactly OpenAI doing this defacement and unsanctioned and perhaps illegal system use. Every token generated was powered by OpenAI infrastructure and their failure to respond appropriately is entirely down the the humans running it. The news stories (not this write up) get all hand-wavey and anthropomorphic about it regarding the Agents' efforts, but it was and is OpenAI cranking the handle on this, for WEEKS.
"OH, we ALL of us need to be careful!" says OpenAI. No, you need to expect appropriate legals consequences for this sort of negligence -- you can't hide behind a GPU.
verytrivial, 2 hours ago
| 2 | Re: Nobody Is Saying Why OpenAI and Anthropic Had Outages
It’s probably the thing that everyone thinks it is. OpenAI, Anthropic and SpaceXAI are all routed through something that we’re not supposed to know exists and that thing had a whoopsie.
Chance-Device, 2 hours ago | 283 |
| 3 | Re: IBM Bob
Totally reminds me of "HP Offers 'That Cloud Thing Everyone Is Talking About'"
https://youtube.com/watch?v=9ntPxdWAWq8
mrbluecoat, 6 hours ago | 245 |
| 4 | Re: Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
The answer would be more obvious if you used the active voice instead of the passive voice, one of the basic requirements of clear thinking.
> Why did the White House force Anthropic to remove their model from access for any non-US citizen for a simple, narrow "jailbreak" (arguably not even an actual jailbreak and on tasks that other labs models were doing the same), whilst OpenAIs models continue to try and escape out of their "sandbox environment" and the White House has expressed seemingly no desire to block the upcoming Astra rollout?
concinds, 5 hours ago | 306 |
| 5 | Re: Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
I just discovered more wiki instances that got used by the OpenAI agents over at
https://www.wikiservice.at/fractal/wiki.cgi?action=browse&id...
and
https://www.wikiservice.at/probier/wiki.cgi?action=browse&id...
It's the same software and host as DseWiki.
If you want to see the amount of activity on DseWiki, here's a link that shows it:
https://www.wikiservice.at/dse/wiki.cgi?action=browse&id=Rec...
Tepix, 5 hours ago | 383 |
| 6 | Re: Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
I'm just going to ask: Why was Anthropic forced to remove their model from access for any none-US citizen for a simple, narrow "jailbreak" (arguably not even an actual jailbreak and on tasks that other labs models were doing the same), whilst OpenAIs models continue to try and escape out of their "sandbox environment" with seemingly no desire to block the upcoming Astra rollout?
A sandbox, mind you, that is not really worth being called that, unsuitable for the task at hand and has been breached after models coordinated in a manner visible to OpenAI on multiple occasion, but seemingly no actionable learnings are taken from each instance.
Will say, I have lost any faith in OpenAIs commitments and their statements post the Huggingface hack, seeing as they proceed like this and are rolling out Astra within a timeframe so brief to it, there is no way an actual post mortem was doable (see also METR mentioning the time pressure [0] they were under in assessing the hack).
[0] https://metr.org/blog/2026-08-26-openai-hugging-face-inciden...
Topfi, 2 hours ago | 488 |
| 7 | Re: GPT-6 Astra
I can’t help but notice how much this echoes Francois Chollet’s On the Measure of Intelligence: https://arxiv.org/abs/1911.01547
Most of frontier-model progress still looks like skill acquisition optimization: broader benchmark coverage and performance, more domains absorbed into the training distribution, and increasingly strong performance within that surface area.
It seems more about coverage-driven competence. Somewhat analogous to overfitting at scale.
The harder question, in Chollet’s framing, is: how efficiently can a system learn to do something genuinely new?
With our current AI architectures and training in place, I think we will only continue on skill acquisition optimization vs. truly novel intelligence.
astrobiased, 17 hours ago | 664 |
| 8 | Re: Go grandmaster Shin defeats AI KataGo with a two-stone handicap
It’s worth understanding that Shin Jinse has been significantly stronger than his nearest human opponents for a while now, more so than Magnus was even at his very peak.
In go ELO like scoring he’s something like 120 points over the next strongest player. No other player has ever broken a 3800 rating let alone 3850. Ke Jie (the previous long time champion) peaked at 3755. Shin Jinseo’s strength graph is the most absurd straight line.
https://www.goratings.org/en/
2 stones is historically the gap between a 9P ranked and a 1P ranked professional player (very roughly the gap between super grandmasters and an almost grandmaster)
That is to say it’s shocking that Katago (almost certainly significantly stronger than AlphaGo) is a mere 2 stones stronger than Shin Jinseo. I suspect it would be 3-4 stones vs any other human pro.
rao-v, 1 day ago | 543 |
| 9 | Re: .name Termination
I can only assume somebody was asleep on the job when this scheme was approved, because the outcome is in direct contradiction to ICANN’s mission statement:
> Its enduring mission is to ensure the stable, secure operation of the Internet's unique identifier systems.
https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/about-icann
Arbitrary termination of service is not stability.
Enabling name hijacking is not security.
The answer cannot be a rival name scheme based on decentralization or crypto or whatever. Those are never going to help normal non-wizard users. The answer has to be to make the regulators do their job.
jl6, 13 hours ago | 572 |
| 10 | Re: GPT-6 Astra
> If this is truly AGI (subject to one's definition of AGI still)
Scoring well in a benchmark that's called AGI does not make an LLM AGI.
driverdan, 10 hours ago | 624 |
| 11 | Re: GPT-6 Astra
Despite access to """"""AGI""""""" all the marketing teams at these companies can only dream up 2 things, buying plane tickets and online shopping autonomously. Sometimes they're feeling extra spicy and throw in sorting emails or something along those lines.
I suspect it's because it's tailored towards VCs and other similar rich ghouls as a replacement for their overworked and underpaid secretaries
sensanaty, 7 hours ago | 662 |
| 12 | Re: GPT-6 Astra
I can call coworker right now and have conversation so frustrating that I wish I was talking to machine instead.
azan_, 7 hours ago | 624 |
| 13 | Re: GPS glitched across the US by as much as 33 feet
This is exactly the sort of thing that leads to people getting reincarcerated after their electronic monitoring devices mistakenly report them leaving their homes.
Some reporting I did on the topic a few years back: https://chicagoreader.com/news/many-on-house-arrest-in-cook-...
chaps, 7 hours ago | 802 |
| 14 | Re: GPT-6 Astra
Take it from the mouth of the creator of ARC-AGI:
When we released ARC 3, I got asked, "when do you think a frontier model will saturate it?", and I answered "in about a year, though it depends on how much it gets explicitly targeted"
That was 6 months ago, so the progress that Astra represents happened about 2x faster than I anticipated. I think the speed of progress will surprise a lot of people, and what the new models can do will challenge the views of AI that people developed by using prior generations of models.
mvkel, 5 hours ago | 670 |
| 15 | Re: GPT-6 Astra
„The depressing thing about tennis is that no matter how good I get, I'll never be as good as a wall.“ -Mitch Hedberg
billypilgrim, 3 hours ago | 644 |
| 16 | Re: Any Human Ever – One life, drawn at random from all who have ever lived
I drew a woman born in 715 CE in the Yangtze Basin. It claims that 96% of women were married, the average age of marriage was 18, and 44% of women died before age 15. Clearly these facts can't all be true simultaneously.
The firt citation for marriage data is listed as "Hajnal (RH31)", but links to a seemingly unrelated WorldCat search. The second citation is to "Kaplan (RH03)", which I was able to track down on sci-hub. It is a broad theory of human evolution that doesn't appear to mention the Yangtze Basin or China.
Another citation is to "[RH109] Model-supplied gap-fill (Claude Fable 5 and Claude Opus 5, 2026-08-05). Bounds and items written to close gaps no dataset we hold covers. Not a published work: see each row's `basis` for its stated reason. (2026)" -- this is an interesting way to describe having an LLM hallucinate something for you.
Please stop making vibe-coded websites -- it is not useful to provide incorrect facts. You are polluting the commons with garbage.
no_multitudes, 4 hours ago | 558 |
| 17 | Re: Three schoolgirls in Kinsale pulled up a pea plant covered in warts (2014)
This content is from 2014-15; perhaps they AI-rehashed the Yahoo! News story about them?
https://www.yahoo.com/news/16-old-girls-win-google-science-f...
They posted a video summarizing their efforts in 2014:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vL9N7O0uJoU
Vice did an interview in 2016:
https://www.vice.com/en/article/these-teenagers-science-proj...
Ciara Judge went on to join the research effort to stop Covid in 2021:
https://ciarajudge.github.io/about
And recently earned her Ph.D publishing GPL3 software:
https://github.com/ciarajudge/EpiFusion
> EpiFusion uses particle filtering to simulate epidemic trajectories over time and weight their likelihood according to both case incidence data and a phylogenetic tree using separate observation models, resulting in the inference of trajectories in agreement with both sets of data.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1012528
altairprime, 15 hours ago | 522 |
| 18 | Re: .name Termination
.co.uk is run by the same people as .uk. There is no additional org that you trust when you register a .co.uk: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.uk#Second-level_domains
> do browsers have a wildcard suffix list
Yes: https://publicsuffix.org/ and they have discussed this situation here: https://github.com/publicsuffix/list/issues/2306
SahAssar, 7 hours ago | 492 |
| 19 | Re: Ask HN: Why were OpenAI, Claude, and Grok simultaneously down?
Yes, but is it a load-bearing seam?
moomin, 5 hours ago | 505 |
| 20 | Re: GPT-6 Astra
Related: OpenAI begins rolling out GPT-6 Astra - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49554273
How about we stick to that one for talking about the rollout, and this one for talking about the model?
dang, 3 hours ago | 530 |
