The Classical Wisdom Tradition
Відкрити в Telegram
Exploring the spirituality inherited by Europe from Greece and Rome. X: https://x.com/CWT_knowthyself
Показати більше2 565
Підписники
+324 години
+37 днів
+1930 днів
Завантажуємо дані
Схожі канали
Хмара тегів
Немає даних
Виникли проблеми? Будь ласка, оновіть сторінку або зверніться до нашого support-менеджера.
Вхідні та вихідні згадування
---
---
---
---
---
---
Залучення підписників
листопад '26лист '26
листопад '26
+49
в 0 каналах
жовтень '26
+178
в 2 каналах
Get PRO
вересень '260
в 2 каналах
Get PRO
серпень '260
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
липень '260
в 6 каналах
Get PRO
червень '260
в 5 каналах
Get PRO
травень '260
в 4 каналах
Get PRO
квітень '260
в 3 каналах
Get PRO
березень '260
в 5 каналах
Get PRO
лютий '260
в 3 каналах
Get PRO
січень '260
в 5 каналах
Get PRO
грудень '250
в 3 каналах
Get PRO
листопад '250
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
жовтень '250
в 6 каналах
Get PRO
вересень '250
в 9 каналах
Get PRO
серпень '250
в 2 каналах
Get PRO
липень '250
в 1 каналах
Get PRO
червень '250
в 2 каналах
Get PRO
травень '250
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
квітень '250
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
березень '250
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
лютий '250
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
січень '250
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
грудень '24
+15
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
листопад '24
+79
в 2 каналах
Get PRO
жовтень '24
+83
в 4 каналах
Get PRO
вересень '24
+87
в 6 каналах
Get PRO
серпень '24
+100
в 5 каналах
Get PRO
липень '24
+54
в 9 каналах
Get PRO
червень '24
+108
в 14 каналах
Get PRO
травень '24
+76
в 11 каналах
Get PRO
квітень '24
+135
в 16 каналах
Get PRO
березень '24
+105
в 14 каналах
Get PRO
лютий '24
+98
в 15 каналах
Get PRO
січень '24
+121
в 14 каналах
Get PRO
грудень '23
+114
в 22 каналах
Get PRO
листопад '23
+96
в 16 каналах
Get PRO
жовтень '23
+48
в 11 каналах
Get PRO
вересень '23
+106
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
серпень '23
+101
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
липень '23
+173
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
червень '23
+34
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
травень '23
+91
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
квітень '23
+74
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
березень '23
+58
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
лютий '23
+103
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
січень '23
+99
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
грудень '22
+31
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
листопад '22
+50
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
жовтень '22
+36
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
вересень '22
+56
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
серпень '22
+54
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
липень '22
+220
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
червень '22
+104
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
травень '22
+103
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
квітень '22
+188
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
березень '22
+116
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
лютий '22
+99
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
січень '22
+191
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
грудень '21
+103
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
листопад '21
+66
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
жовтень '21
+3
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
вересень '21
+17
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
серпень '21
+30
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
липень '21
+65
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
червень '21
+43
в 0 каналах
Get PRO
травень '21
+301
в 0 каналах
| Дата | Залучення підписників | Згадування | Канали | |
| 22 листопада | 0 | |||
| 21 листопада | +4 | |||
| 20 листопада | +2 | |||
| 19 листопада | 0 | |||
| 18 листопада | +3 | |||
| 17 листопада | +1 | |||
| 16 листопада | +1 | |||
| 15 листопада | +1 | |||
| 14 листопада | +1 | |||
| 13 листопада | +1 | |||
| 12 листопада | +2 | |||
| 11 листопада | +2 | |||
| 10 листопада | +2 | |||
| 09 листопада | +4 | |||
| 08 листопада | +6 | |||
| 07 листопада | +2 | |||
| 06 листопада | +2 | |||
| 05 листопада | +3 | |||
| 04 листопада | +2 | |||
| 03 листопада | +3 | |||
| 02 листопада | +4 | |||
| 01 листопада | +3 |
Дописи каналу
In the previous poll, voters chose to stick closer to the Greek for divine names. But do you favor strict transliteration or compromise?
18 лист, 15:30
| 2 | "You will best honor God by making your mind like unto Him, and this you can do by virtue alone. For only virtue can draw the soul upward to that which is akin to it."
Porphyry, Letter to his Wife Marcella 16 | 400 |
| 3 | The above post does a good job of disproving "hard polytheism" as the default position.
My own move on this topic has been to say that I don't care if Platonic "soft polytheism" is the oldest or original view since, first of all, it is true, and secondly, platonism is what I have actually inherited, regardless of whether it is the oldest view. I'm also not sure Platonism even is "soft polytheism".
Nonetheless, since so many people, for reasons utterly mysterious to me, get stuck on this, it is perhaps worth occasionally addressing it.
Platonism, far from being a sterling stone to Christian monotheism, is in reality very much of a deeply ancient lineage of theology. | 378 |
| 4 | Information everyone should know, because many people out there prey on ignorance of this material.
There is no default “hard polytheism” at all in the Vedic tradition. No positive evidence has been given for such a default and it is instead contradicted by all of the overt theological statements of the earliest hymns.
“Hard polytheism” is a fairly radical modern construction (often a constructed fantasy not matching ancient beliefs) whose alleged presence in a given text has to actually be supported with evidence, but that evidence doesn’t exist for the Rig Veda.
In reality, the only overt evidence from the very earliest layer of the Rig Veda expresses a mystical “soft polytheism” (another dumb/imprecise modern term) that is never counteracted by any overt statements of “hard polytheism.”
Everyone should be aware that claims of “hard polytheism” usually operate as “hard polytheism of the gaps”.
Where the metaphysics of a historical polytheism survive in a form that is vague or covered by silence, “hard polytheism” is claimed as some kind of default without positive evidence. This is of course circular reasoning, a double standard of evidence, and historically naive.
But even worse than Rig Vedic hard polytheism being an “of the gaps” assertion, in the Rig Veda there is no early gap where such an unstated hard polytheism can be baselessly claimed in this way. From the earliest hymns the theological statements already articulate some other kind of mystical or soft polytheism and contain recognized symbols of an absolute (Pillar of Heaven, the Imperishable, the Syllable that underpins the power of the Gods, the One) that are treated mystically.
The direct textual evidence for this is extensive and self-explanatory. The translation of Rig Veda used is Jamison and Brereton (2014).
See the link below:
https://x.com/StructuralMyth1/status/2120604785451864136 | 262 |
| 5 | Which convention should I follow for divine names in the book? | 301 |
| 6 | Proclus teaches that the seeds are scattered in autumn and hidden in the earth through winter: "...it is for this reason that, when it comes to the seasons, they say that winter belongs to Kronos, since they hide the seeds under the earth just as Kronos hid his own offspring, if you want to put it in a theological manner. Or if you wish to put it in natural terms, it is due to the cold with which winter endows the things that come to be." (Proclus, Commentary on Plato's Republic 61.20-62.19, excerpt)
The Orphic hymn calls to Boreas: "Bring calm to all within the sky, and clear the moisture from Aether's beautiful eye." (Orphic Hymn 79, rendered in modern English from Thomas Taylor's translation) Hesiod, in Works and Days, shows how to meet winter's coming. Prepare for the season: "Then put on, as I tell you, a soft coat and a tunic to the feet to shield your body, and you should weave thick woof on thin warp." Winter asks for a change in how we live, for "in this season, let your oxen have half their usual food, but let a man have more; for the helpful nights are long." (Works and Days 536-563, trans. Thomas Taylor)
The long nights are a gift. Take time to align with the season the gods have created around us, and use it to reflect on your life with the daily exercise from the Golden Verses of the Pythagoreans (40-46):
"Do not admit sleep upon your gentle eyes before you have reviewed each of the actions of the day three times. 'Where have I transgressed? What did I accomplish? What duty did I neglect?' All, from the first to the last, examine. If you have done wretched things, reprimand yourself, but if you have done good things, rejoice." | 354 |
| 7 | The Season of Contemplation
Boreas, the north wind, brings winter, the season of contemplation, when all things draw inward. It is a time to gather by the hearth with a quiet read and let the mind sink into deeper thought.
(J.C. Leyendecker, Man Seated Before Fireplace) | 306 |
| 8 | LXXIX. Orphic Hymn to the North Wind [Boreas]
The Fumigation from Frankincense.
Boreas, whose wint’ry blasts, terrific, tear the bosom of the deep surrounding air;
Cold icy pow’r, approach, and fav’ring blow, and Thrace a while desert expos’d to snow:
The misty station of the air dissolve, with pregnant clouds, whose frames in show’rs resolve:
Serenely temper all within the sky, and wipe from moisture, Æther’s beauteous eye.
(Painting: Phoebus and Boreas (1879), by Gustave Moreau (1826–1898)) | 416 |
| 9 | "Then put on, as I tell you, a soft coat and a tunic to the feet to shield your body, and you should weave thick woof on thin warp. Clothe yourself in this so that your hair may keep still and not bristle and stand up on end all over your body. On your feet, lace close-fitting boots of the hide of a slaughtered ox, thickly lined with felt inside. And when the season of frost comes on, stitch together skins of firstling kids with ox-sinew, to put over your back and to keep off the rain. On your head, wear a shaped cap of felt to keep your ears from getting wet, for the dawn is chill when Boreas has once made his onslaught, and at dawn a fruitful mist is spread over the earth from starry heaven upon the fields of blessed men: it is drawn from the ever flowing rivers and is raised high above the earth by windstorm, and sometimes it turns to rain towards evening, and sometimes to wind when Thracian Boreas huddles the thick clouds. Finish your work and return home ahead of him, and do not let the dark cloud from heaven wrap around you and make your body clammy and soak your clothes. Avoid it; for this is the hardest month, wintry, hard for sheep and hard for men. In this season, let your oxen have half their usual food, but let a man have more; for the helpful nights are long. Observe all this until the year is ended and you have nights and days of equal length, and Earth, the mother of all, bears again her various fruit."
Hesiod, Works and Days 536–563 | 380 |
| 10 | "Be assured that the essence of piety towards the gods lies in this: to form right opinions about them, that they exist and govern the universe well and justly, and to fix yourself in this duty: to obey them and yield to them in everything which happens, and to willingly follow it as being accomplished by the wisest intelligence. ... But it also becomes incumbent on every one to offer libations and sacrifices and first-fruits, according to the customs of his country, purely, and not heedlessly nor negligently; not stingily nor extravagantly."
Epictetus, The Handbook 31 | 338 |
| 11 | AN ALLEGORY OF PAGAN RECONSTRUCTIONISM
It is the year 3026. A group calling themselves the Americanists seeks to live in accord with the American Way. They believe in making money, some of them wear cowboy hats, and so on.
One of them decides to research US law. Upon concluding his research, it occurs to him that it was not illegal in America to be a bad parent.
Armed with this insight, he takes to the podium at the next Americanist meeting and declares, "Like all red-blooded American men, I support your right as an American to be a bad parent! Yeehaw!" | 442 |
| 12 | Continued.
It is true that historical pagan states were relatively laissez-faire compared to historical Abrahamic ones, but should that matter much to me? Am I trying to create a pagan country? Or am I trying to be a spiritual person? Even if I am trying to create a pagan country, why is it assumed I would base it on, say, historical Athens or Rome versus Plato's Laws which mandated a basic orthodoxy? And since after all I'm not creating a pagan country, why would I reduce my spirituality to the bare minimum of what would keep me out of Athenian or Roman jails? Why would I promote that bare minimum to others? If, on the other hand, I am trying to be a spiritual person, should I not seek out spiritual wisdom? If truth is what matters, then basic truths about the gods certainly matter. If it's true, for example, that the gods are providential and good, then having that correct opinion is much better than viewing the gods as a heavenly mafia we must pay tribute to with offerings. None of this means we must all agree on the intricacies of metaphysics, but placing ritual orthopraxy over basic orthodoxy elevates historical states, or the statistical average of the historian, over the best advice of our theologians. And it does mean that we should, as they did, strongly encourage the exploration of what is true, even though we allow for a variety of conclusions about what the truth is.
We must leave behind bad ideas or we will never reach our most ambitious goals. | 418 |
| 13 | ORTHODOXY VERSUS ORTHOPRAXY
The European spiritual community has been poisoned by the absurd idea that your beliefs and opinions do not matter so long as your behaviors are correct.
Socrates, Plato, Epictetus, and a host of other actual European pagans who we can read about in detail would be shocked to hear that beliefs do not matter! On the contrary, many of the most sophisticated "pagans" who left us with their thoughts on paper were quite clear: it matters very much what you believe!
Think about it: on this view, an atheist, for example, who performs a ritual is more pious than a believer who prays constantly and diligently works to purge their souls of vice, but who doesn't perform a particular ritual. This makes no sense! It also has the practical consequence that if we lack specific ritual details, we are cut off from God because we can't behave correctly! | 430 |
| 14 | The most incredible, beautiful, sophisticated, life changing, and Western spirituality is sitting right there on our bookshelves. All we have to do is take the books down and read them!
The skeleton key can be summarized in one word: EDUCATION. Once you understand that education = spirituality, the Western spiritual tradition reveals itself to you! But education implies curriculum.... We are very close to fully restoring the true vision of Platonic Western education (spirituality): soon, we will be able to produce textbooks backed by tradition. From there, the sky is the limit. But this initial phase of laying the foundation is critically important and cannot be skipped or rushed!
We are going to restore our true spiritual tradition, and it is going to start happening fast. Most of the difficult groundwork has been laid (but not quite!). | 413 |
| 15 | RECONSTRUCTION VERSUS RESTORATION
Imagine you have a 500 piece jigsaw puzzle. The pieces are mixed up inside the box. Sadly, you lost the cover and 10 pieces. So, you have 490 pieces but you don't know what the picture is. You remember it's a picture of a castle, but you can't remember the details.
If you really wanted to, you could figure out how the pieces fit together. It would be hard and it would take a while, but you could do it.
Here's the key point: the pieces actually do fit together. It's not a theory or a guess. The missing 10 will have to be inferred or reconstructed, but you would wait until you put the 490 together before reconstructing the missing 10.
Platonic classical spirituality is like this. At this point, we have put about 400 pieces together. Not much is missing! | 403 |
| 16 | "Life is long enough, and it has been given in sufficiently generous measure to allow the accomplishment of the very greatest things if the whole of it is well invested."
Seneca, On the shortness of life 1 | 555 |
| 17 | "Receive an injury rather than do one."
Publius Syrus, Sententiae 5 | 624 |
| 18 | ⚖️ Measure Is Most Excellent
Demophilus (Similitudes 59) writes:
"'Measure is most excellent,' says one of the wise men, and so we being persuaded of this, O most friendly and pious Asclepiades, now finish our precepts for life."
In medicine, knowing the measure is what turns a substance into an excellent remedy. The same is true of our lives: knowing our measure brings us to a healthy life.
Reflect:
🔹 Where does excess hide in your life?
🔹 Where do you feel lack?
🔹 What would be the healthy measure? | 681 |
| 19 | "It is necessary that he who exercises should avoid fatigue, and he who is prosperous, envy."
The Similitudes of Demophilus 58 | 559 |
| 20 | The four cardinal virtues are the foundation of a well-ordered life. Which one are you working on right now? (Tell us why you chose it in the comments.) | 722 |
