ch
Feedback

不要被骗子欺骗!Telemetrio 会找到并标记这些频道 👉 如果想查看标记,请订阅

📚 CA Finalists

📚 CA Finalists

前往频道在 Telegram

👨🏻‍🎓Welcome To Our Channel For Notes & Lectures For CA Final Students 🌀Join Us https://t.me/CABornToFight/13074 📥 Contact Us @CABornToFightHelpBot ⛔bit.ly/CABornToFightAdvtDisclaimer ⛔bit.ly/CABornToFightContentDisclaimer ❤️Thank You

显示更多

📈 Telegram 频道 📚 CA Finalists 的分析概览

频道 📚 CA Finalists (@cafinal_borntofight) 英语 语言赛道中的 是活跃参与者。目前社区聚集了 11 760 名订阅者,在 教育 类别中位列第 17 243,并在 印度 地区排名第 32 431 位。

📊 受众指标与增长动态

自 невідомо 创建以来,项目保持高速增长,吸引了 11 760 名订阅者。

根据 20 十一月, 2026 的最新数据,频道保持稳定运转。过去 30 天订阅人数变化为 -14,过去 24 小时变化为 2,整体触达仍然可观。

  • 认证状态: 未认证
  • 互动率 (ER): 平均受众互动率为 5.67%。内容发布后 24 小时内通常能获得 3.05% 的反应,占订阅者总量。
  • 帖子覆盖: 每篇帖子平均可获得 667 次浏览,首日通常累积 359 次浏览。
  • 互动与反馈: 受众积极参与,单帖平均反应数为 1。
  • 主题关注点: 内容集中在 catestseries.org, guidance, evaluation, sir, faculty 等核心主题上。

📝 描述与内容策略

作者将该频道定位为表达主观观点的平台:
“👨🏻‍🎓Welcome To Our Channel For Notes & Lectures For CA Final Students 🌀Join Us https://t.me/CABornToFight/13074 📥 Contact Us @CABornToFightHelpBot ⛔bit.ly/CABornToFightAdvtDisclaimer ⛔bit.ly/CABornToFightContentDisclaimer ❤️Thank You”

凭借高频更新(最新数据采集于 21 十一月, 2026),频道始终保持新鲜度与高覆盖。分析显示受众积极互动,使其成为 教育 类别中的关键影响点。

11 760
订阅者
+224 小时
-207 天
-1430 天
吸引订阅者
11月 '26
十一月 '26
+50
在3个频道中
十月 '26
+21
在10个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '26
+39
在6个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '26
+38
在5个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '26
+43
在6个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '26
+41
在4个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '26
+31
在4个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '26
+34
在4个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '26
+17
在4个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '26
+25
在4个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '26
+45
在4个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '25
+26
在4个频道中
Get PRO
十一月 '25
+48
在5个频道中
Get PRO
十月 '25
+34
在4个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '25
+53
在4个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '25
+59
在4个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '25
+52
在5个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '25
+41
在7个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '25
+69
在9个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '25
+69
在6个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '25
+86
在8个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '25
+44
在7个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '25
+113
在6个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '24
+130
在7个频道中
Get PRO
十一月 '24
+134
在8个频道中
Get PRO
十月 '24
+142
在7个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '24
+159
在7个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '24
+207
在9个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '24
+677
在7个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '24
+644
在8个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '24
+909
在10个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '24
+907
在13个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '24
+634
在13个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '24
+545
在10个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '24
+579
在10个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '23
+316
在10个频道中
Get PRO
十一月 '23
+129
在7个频道中
Get PRO
十月 '23
+356
在14个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '23
+368
在0个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '23
+649
在0个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '23
+335
在0个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '23
+236
在0个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '23
+432
在0个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '23
+147
在0个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '23
+195
在0个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '23
+321
在0个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '23
+188
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '22
+94
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十一月 '22
+96
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十月 '22
+129
在0个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '22
+146
在0个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '22
+65
在0个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '22
+174
在0个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '22
+90
在0个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '22
+154
在0个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '22
+95
在0个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '22
+85
在0个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '22
+34
在0个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '22
+89
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '21
+82
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十一月 '21
+27
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十月 '21
+47
在0个频道中
Get PRO
九月 '21
+37
在0个频道中
Get PRO
八月 '21
+32
在0个频道中
Get PRO
七月 '21
+71
在0个频道中
Get PRO
六月 '21
+77
在0个频道中
Get PRO
五月 '21
+86
在0个频道中
Get PRO
四月 '21
+68
在0个频道中
Get PRO
三月 '21
+80
在0个频道中
Get PRO
二月 '21
+76
在0个频道中
Get PRO
一月 '21
+123
在0个频道中
Get PRO
十二月 '20
+7 093
在0个频道中
日期
订阅者增长
提及
频道
20 十一月+2
19 十一月+2
18 十一月0
17 十一月+1
16 十一月0
15 十一月0
14 十一月0
13 十一月+11
12 十一月+10
11 十一月+2
10 十一月0
09 十一月+2
08 十一月+1
07 十一月0
06 十一月+2
05 十一月0
04 十一月+8
03 十一月+1
02 十一月+3
01 十一月+5
频道帖子
🚨Follow the 10X Wealth with CA Ravie Agarwal channel on WhatsApp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VbEd9zH4yltVeia4Ge3X 📉 Click the above 🔗🔗 above to join in. ( Note : Soon the channel will be made private and new members will not be able to join in)
19 11月, 13:51

2
40 days - 2 Revisions as per ICAI Pattern only with CAtestseries.org✍️📈 Experts will help you prepare for the ICAI Sept/Nov
40 days - 2 Revisions as per ICAI Pattern only with CAtestseries.org✍️📈 Experts will help you prepare for the ICAI Sept/Nov Examination 2026 ✅ Application-based Questions ✅ Notes + Doubt solving + Mentoring + Guidance Videos ✅ Suggested Answers + Toppers Sheets for comparison ✅ Study Planners + Imp Q’s + Imp MCQs & Case Study MCQs ✅ 17+ unique techniques to enhance performance ✅ Systematic, effective revision road map Coupon Code - CARESULT Register: https://www.catestseries.org/register.php ▶️ WhatsApp: 78886-34515 | CAtestSeries.org
121
3
CA Foundation Jan 2027 Strategy!🔥 Enroll in our High-Yield Mock Tests Experts will help you prepare for the ICAI Jan Examina
CA Foundation Jan 2027 Strategy!🔥 Enroll in our High-Yield Mock Tests Experts will help you prepare for the ICAI Jan Examination 2026 ✅ Application-based Questions ✅ Notes + Doubt solving + Mentoring + Guidance Videos ✅ Suggested Answers + Toppers Sheets for comparison ✅ Study Planners + Imp Q’s + Imp MCQs & Case Study MCQs ✅ 17+ unique techniques to enhance performance ✅ Systematic, effective revision road map Coupon Code - CARESULT Register: https://www.catestseries.org/register.php ▶️ WhatsApp: 78886-34515 | CAtestSeries.org
161
4
CA_Final_Nov26_Observations_Subjectwise.pdf
501
5
Nov'26 Observation.docx
647
6
Observation Nov"26 exams by Dhruv Tanna
332
7
ADDITIONAL CONCERN – OVERALL LENGTH OF THE PAPER Apart from the above MCQ-related issues, the overall length of the November 2026 IBS paper was considerable. The case studies contained extensive factual information, multiple statutory provisions, accounting treatments and calculations. Candidates were required to analyse lengthy case studies before even attempting the associated MCQs. The AVSM case study, in particular, involved substantial factual information spanning several pages and tested multiple areas of the syllabus. The time required to comprehend and analyse the case studies significantly affected the time available for answering the questions. Consequently, candidates faced considerable difficulty completing the paper within the prescribed time, irrespective of their level of preparation. We request that the overall length and time requirements of the paper also be considered while evaluating the examination. OUR HUMBLE REQUEST TO ICAI In light of the above observations, we sincerely request the Examination Department and the concerned authorities to: 1. Conduct a question-wise technical review of all the above-mentioned MCQs. 2. Verify the factual inconsistencies, statutory references, calculation requirements and answer options. 3. Reconsider questions where the information provided permits more than one reasonable interpretation or does not support a unique correct answer. 4. Consider awarding grace marks or appropriate compensatory marks for questions found to be defective or ambiguous. 5. Where necessary, consider awarding marks to all candidates for the affected questions rather than penalising candidates for deficiencies in the question paper. 6. Take the overall length and time constraints of the examination into consideration while determining an appropriate evaluation approach. We understand that ICAI maintains high standards in conducting professional examinations. However, it is equally important that the questions presented to candidates are factually consistent, technically accurate and capable of producing a clear and unambiguous answer. The concerns raised above are genuine and relate to the formulation of the questions themselves, rather than merely the difficulty of the examination. We therefore request ICAI to kindly consider these representations sympathetically and take appropriate corrective action to ensure fairness and uniformity in the evaluation of all candidates. We sincerely hope that the concerns of the students will receive due attention before the declaration of results. Thank you for your time and consideration. Yours faithfully, Name: [Your Name] Registration Number: [Registration Number] Roll Number: [Roll Number] Email ID: [Email ID] Mobile Number: [Mobile Number]
317
8
Since MCQ 4.3 requires calculation of the total compensation payable to the Whole-Time Director and CFO, this inconsistency directly affects the computation and potentially the correct answer option. This is a factual and chronological inconsistency in the question paper itself and deserves specific reconsideration. CASE STUDY 5 8. MCQ 5.1 – Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) The question requires calculation of OEE based on the production data of a CNC machine during an eight-hour shift. The information includes scheduled tool changes, safety checks, machine breakdowns and waiting time for raw castings, along with the production quantity, defective units and ideal cycle time. The primary concern is the classification of scheduled tool changes and safety checks while determining planned production time and availability. If these activities are treated as planned downtime, the resulting OEE differs from the calculation where they are included in operating time. The distinction is particularly important because the answer options are closely placed, and a difference in the classification of downtime can result in a different final percentage. The question should have expressly clarified which activities were to be excluded from planned production time and which were to be treated as operating downtime. It is requested that the intended treatment and all available answer options be verified. If multiple interpretations are technically defensible, appropriate benefit should be extended to candidates. 9. MCQ 5.3 – Capital Gains and Exemption under Section 54D of the Income-tax Act, 1961 The question requires computation of the taxable amount of capital gains arising from compulsory acquisition of land. The case study provides details concerning the original purchase of land, its intended use for construction of a warehouse, the compulsory acquisition proceedings and the compensation received in different financial years. The concern is regarding the applicability of Section 54D of the Income-tax Act, 1961, particularly the statutory condition relating to the use of the land or building for industrial purposes for the prescribed period immediately preceding compulsory acquisition. The question requires candidates to determine the taxability of the capital gain while considering the facts concerning the nature and use of the acquired property. However, the facts and the intended application of the statutory eligibility conditions require reconsideration. The question should have clearly established whether the property satisfies the conditions prescribed under Section 54D and whether the exemption is available in the circumstances described. It is requested that the eligibility conditions, calculation and corresponding answer options be independently verified. 10. MCQ 5.4 – Vacancy in the Office of CFO under Section 203(4) of the Companies Act, 2013 This question contains a direct chronological inconsistency in the facts relating to the resignation of the CFO. The case study states that: - Mr. Sanjay's resignation letter was dated 15 December 2025. - The resignation letter was received by the company on 5 December 2025. - The resignation was accepted. - The vacancy could not be filled by the end of March 2026. The problem is that the company is stated to have received and accepted the resignation on 5 December 2025, whereas the resignation letter itself is dated 15 December 2025. This creates uncertainty regarding the actual date on which the vacancy arose. Furthermore, the MCQ contains statements involving the date of occurrence of the vacancy, the six-month period for filling the vacancy and the requirement of approval by the Board and shareholders. The statements combine multiple legal requirements, and the conflicting dates in the case study directly affect the determination of the statutory timeline. It is requested that the question be reviewed with reference to Section 203(4) of the Companies Act, 2013, and the applicable provisions governing the appointment of Key Managerial Personnel.
191
9
It is requested that the classification of each statement and the corresponding MCQ answer be independently verified. 4. MCQ 3.5 – Job Work provisions under the CGST Act, 2017 The question contains five statements concerning input tax credit, movement of goods to job workers, non-return of inputs and waste and scrap generated during job work. Particular concern arises regarding Statement (v), which states that where the job worker is not registered under GST, the principal may supply waste and scrap generated during job work from the job worker's premises only if such premises have been declared as an additional place of business of the principal. The distinction between the treatment applicable to registered and unregistered job workers creates uncertainty regarding the statutory conditions governing such supplies. The question should have more clearly distinguished the conditions applicable to the principal and the job worker, particularly concerning the declaration of premises and the supply of waste and scrap. It is requested that Statement (v) and the corresponding answer combination be reconsidered in light of the relevant provisions of the CGST Act and Rules. CASE STUDY 4 5. MCQ 4.1 – Value Proposition Map The question requires candidates to classify four statements under Pain, Gain, Pain Reliever and Gain Creator. The statements concerning schedule flexibility, lower travel costs, fast charging, reduction in recharging delays and intelligent route planning have considerable conceptual overlap. For example: - Greater schedule flexibility and lower travel costs can be interpreted as customer Gains. - Concerns regarding loss of productive time constitute customer Pains. - Fast charging can be classified as a Pain Reliever, while the additional convenience it provides can also be interpreted as a Gain Creator. The options contain closely worded combinations, making it difficult to distinguish between the intended classifications. Since the question is an MCQ and does not provide an opportunity for explanatory justification, the ambiguity directly affects the marks available. It is requested that the classification and answer options be reviewed. 6. MCQ 4.2 – Two-Stage Dividend Growth Model This question contains a material inconsistency regarding the dividend growth period. The case study specifically states that the company expects dividend growth at 12% per annum over the next two years. However, the same paragraph subsequently states that beyond the initial three-year period, the dividend growth rate is expected to moderate to 10% per annum. This creates uncertainty regarding the dividend growth rate applicable during the third year. The distinction is extremely significant because the question requires computation of intrinsic value per share under the Two-Stage Dividend Growth Model. Taking 12% growth for two years or three years produces materially different valuations and can change the correct MCQ option. The question should have clearly specified the applicable growth rate for each year. Candidates should not be penalised for adopting a reasonable interpretation of contradictory information supplied in the case study. It is therefore requested that this question be reviewed and appropriate marks be awarded wherever warranted. 7. MCQ 4.3 – Compensation payable to the Whole-Time Director and CFO This question contains a significant chronological inconsistency in the remuneration particulars of the CFO. The case study states that: - Soumya Ghosh was appointed as CFO on 1 October 2025 for a period of three years. - The initial monthly remuneration was ₹3.6 lakh. - The remuneration was subsequently increased to ₹4 lakh per month with effect from April 2025. The difficulty is that the revised remuneration date of April 2025 precedes the actual appointment date of 1 October 2025. Consequently, candidates are left uncertain regarding the remuneration actually applicable during the relevant period.
143
10
To: examfeedback@icai.in Respected Sir/Madam, We, the candidates who appeared for CA Final – Paper 6: Integrated Business Solutions (IBS), November 2026 examination, wish to bring to your attention certain serious concerns regarding the formulation, factual accuracy, statutory interpretation and answer options of multiple-choice questions (MCQs) in the examination paper. Upon a detailed review of the question paper, we have identified approximately 10 MCQs across Case Studies 2 to 5 which require reconsideration. These questions involve apparent factual inconsistencies, ambiguous wording, contradictory information, questionable statutory interpretations and calculation-related issues. The concerns are not merely related to the difficulty level of the examination. They directly affect the ability of candidates to arrive at a unique and technically defensible answer despite having adequate conceptual knowledge. Our question-wise observations are detailed below. CASE STUDY 2 1. MCQ 2.2 – Interpretation of provisions relating to electronic service of notice and assessment proceedings The case study discusses the validity of an electronic notice issued under the Income-tax Act, 1961, an inadvertent clerical error in the assessment order and the subsequent challenge by the assessee regarding improper service of notice. The MCQ requires candidates to identify the legal positions adopted by the Tax Manager. The concern is that the question combines different legal principles concerning: - Validity of notices served electronically. - Effect of clerical errors in assessment orders. - Validity of proceedings where objections regarding improper service have not been raised at the appropriate stage. The statutory basis and intended application of these principles should be clearly distinguishable. The relevant statutory reference and wording, particularly the provisions concerning curable defects and improper service, require verification. It is requested that the intended statutory interpretation and corresponding answer options be reviewed. 2. MCQ 2.5 – Disclosure requirements under Ind AS 1 The question requires candidates to identify observations in the draft financial statements that require reconsideration before approval. The statements involve: - Explicit and unreserved statements of compliance with Ind AS. - Management's selection and application of accounting policies. - Departure from a specific requirement of an Ind AS. - Disclosure of the nature, reasons and financial effects of such departure. The difficulty arises because certain statements appear to overlap or contradict the disclosure requirements applicable to departure from an Ind AS. In particular, the distinction between disclosure of the nature of departure, the reasons for departure and the financial effect of such departure requires careful consideration. The statements should be reviewed against the exact requirements of Ind AS 1 to establish whether the given answer combinations provide a single unambiguous answer. CASE STUDY 3 3. MCQ 3.1 – Classification of Market Risks in Securitisation Transactions The question requires candidates to identify the events representing Market Risks in the securitisation transaction. The case study describes several developments concerning the loan portfolio, including: - Downturn in industrial production. - Reduction in resale values of commercial vehicles. - Reduction in market interest rates. - Reinvestment of funds at lower interest rates. - Mismatch between interest receipts and investor payouts. The concern is that these developments involve different underlying risk categories, including market-related interest rate risk and other risks associated with borrowers, collateral values and securitised loan portfolios. The classification of the stated events under the relevant market-risk categories requires reconsideration, particularly where the underlying facts do not clearly establish the precise nature of the exposure.
112
11
This appears to be a drafting or typographical error in the question paper and may create unnecessary confusion regarding the intended subject matter. Request: It is requested that ICAI take cognisance of the incorrect terminology and ensure that candidates are not adversely affected while evaluating this question. GENERAL SUBMISSION AND REQUEST FOR APPROPRIATE RELIEF The above observations are submitted in good faith and with the objective of maintaining fairness, transparency and uniformity in the evaluation of the examination. It is respectfully submitted that candidates should not be disadvantaged on account of missing factual information, ambiguous wording or incorrect statutory references in the question paper. I therefore request the Examination Department to: 1. Refer the above observations to the concerned subject experts for technical examination. 2. Review the MCQs where missing factual information affects the determination of the correct answer. 3. Consider awarding appropriate marks or accepting alternative legally sustainable answers wherever the question does not provide sufficient information. 4. Ensure that descriptive answers based on the correct statutory provisions are evaluated fairly, particularly where the question itself contains an incorrect reference or terminology. I sincerely hope that the Institute will examine these observations objectively and take appropriate corrective measures in the interest of all candidates who appeared for the November 2026 examination. Thank you for your time and consideration. Yours faithfully, Name: [Candidate Name] Registration Number: [Registration Number] Roll Number: [Roll Number] Examination: CA Final – November 2026 Subject: Paper 5 – Indirect Tax Laws Email: [Email Address] Mobile: [Mobile Number]
95
12
The integrated case study provides that Procto Limited received ₹2,00,000 for transportation of passengers by an omnibus constructed to carry more than six passengers, excluding the driver, owned by Jeet Transport Pvt. Ltd., a registered person in Rajasthan. The question requires candidates to calculate the amount of tax collected at source under Section 52 of the CGST Act, 2017. However, the question does not specify whether the passengers receiving the transportation service are registered or unregistered persons. Further, the place of embarkation of passengers has not been provided. Under Section 12(9) of the IGST Act, 2017: - In the case of a registered recipient, the place of supply is the location of such recipient. - In the case of an unregistered recipient, the place of supply is the place where the passenger embarks on the conveyance for a continuous journey. Therefore, in the absence of the recipient's registration status and relevant place-of-embarkation details, it is not possible to conclusively determine whether the supply is intra-State or inter-State. This directly affects the classification and distribution of TCS between CGST, SGST and IGST. Request: It is requested that ICAI consider the missing factual information and examine whether the available answer options adequately cover the legally possible treatments. PART B – OBSERVATIONS REGARDING DESCRIPTIVE SECTION 4. Question No. 5(b) – Page 30 (5 Marks) Subject: Demand confirmed in excess of the amount specified in the Show Cause Notice and introduction of an additional ground The question provides that Flair and Co. received a Show Cause Notice under Section 74A for FY 2024-25, alleging that ITC claimed in GSTR-3B exceeded the ITC available in GSTR-2B. The Show Cause Notice proposed a tax demand of ₹54,000. However, after considering the taxpayer's reply and reconciliation, the Proper Officer passed an order confirming: (i) ₹60,000 towards excess ITC; and (ii) An additional ₹25,000 towards suppression of purchases reflected in the reply filed by the taxpayer. In this regard, Section 75(7) of the CGST Act, 2017 clearly provides that the amount of tax, interest and penalty demanded in the order shall not exceed the amount specified in the notice. Further, no demand shall be confirmed on grounds other than those specified in the notice. Accordingly, the facts raise two distinct legal concerns: (a) The demand of ₹60,000 exceeds the original proposed demand of ₹54,000. (b) The additional demand of ₹25,000 appears to have been introduced on a separate ground which was not specified in the original Show Cause Notice. The question does not clarify whether a separate notice or any amendment to the original proceedings was issued in respect of the additional allegation. Request: It is requested that ICAI consider the statutory restrictions under Section 75(7) while evaluating the answers and ensure that candidates addressing both the excess demand and the additional ground receive appropriate credit. 5. Question No. 6(b) – Page 31 (4 Marks) Subject: Incorrect terminology and reference to Section 148 of the CGST Act, 2017 The question states: "The Government may, on the recommendation of the Council issue notification prescribing special procedure for certain criminal processes. Elaborate the statement with reference to Section 148 of the CGST Act, 2017." However, Section 148 of the CGST Act, 2017 deals with the special procedure for certain classes of registered persons and not criminal processes. The provision empowers the Government, on the recommendations of the GST Council, to notify certain classes of registered persons and prescribe special procedures to be followed by such persons in relation to registration, furnishing of returns, payment of tax and other specified matters. The expression "criminal processes" is therefore inconsistent with the subject matter of the statutory provision.
90
13
Respected Sir/Madam, Subject: Consolidated Representation Regarding Ambiguities and Errors in CA Final – Indirect Tax Laws Question Paper, November 2026 I wish to bring to your kind attention certain observations and concerns identified upon a detailed examination of the CA Final – Paper 5: Indirect Tax Laws question paper conducted in November 2026. Upon reviewing both the Multiple Choice Questions (30 marks) and the Descriptive Questions (70 marks), I have identified certain questions where essential factual information appears to be missing, statutory provisions have not been appropriately reflected, or the wording may lead to different interpretations while applying the relevant provisions of law. The observations are submitted below for your consideration. PART A – OBSERVATIONS REGARDING MCQ SECTION 1. Question No. 2 – Page 2 (1 Mark) Subject: Incomplete factual information regarding baggage allowance of an Air Hostess The question states that Ms. Ayesha returned to India from the USA by VAYU Airlines and worked as an Air Hostess on the same flight. The details of articles brought by her include chocolates worth ₹1,500, cosmetics worth ₹3,000 and one laptop worth ₹35,000. Candidates are required to determine the assessable value of baggage liable to Customs Duty under Rule 11 of the Baggage Rules, 2026. However, the question does not clarify whether Ms. Ayesha was returning in the ordinary course of her employment as a crew member or on final pay-off upon termination of her engagement with the airline. This distinction is material because Rule 11 prescribes different treatment for crew members depending upon whether they are importing baggage at the time of final pay-off or otherwise. In the absence of this essential information, candidates are required to make an assumption regarding the applicable provision, which may directly affect the determination of baggage allowance and the amount liable to customs duty. Request: It is requested that ICAI consider this ambiguity and provide appropriate moderation or accept all legally sustainable answers arising from the incomplete facts. 2. Question No. 12 – Page 10 (2 Marks) Subject: Missing information regarding classification of hotel premises as Specified Premises The integrated case study states that Gulmohar Restaurant is located in Hotel Manek Pol, where accommodation is provided at ₹6,500 per unit per day. Question No. 12 requires candidates to calculate the output GST payable by Procto Limited, an e-commerce operator, considering the applicability of Section 9(5) of the CGST Act, 2017. However, the question does not provide the following essential information: (a) Whether the hotel premises supplied accommodation services exceeding ₹7,500 per unit per day during the preceding financial year. (b) Whether the hotel operator had filed the prescribed declaration for treating the premises as Specified Premises for the relevant financial year. As per the amended definition of Specified Premises effective from 1 April 2025, the classification depends upon the value of accommodation supplied during the preceding financial year or the prescribed declaration. The current accommodation value of ₹6,500 per unit per day does not independently establish whether the premises qualify as Specified Premises. This classification is crucial because the GST treatment of restaurant services supplied through an e-commerce operator under Section 9(5) differs depending upon whether the restaurant is situated at Specified Premises. Consequently, the missing information directly affects the computation of output tax liability and may lead candidates to different answer options. Request: It is requested that ICAI examine the question and consider appropriate moderation or acceptance of alternative answers, since the essential information required to determine the applicable GST treatment has not been provided. 3. Question No. 13 – Page 11 (2 Marks) Subject: Insufficient information regarding place of supply for passenger transportation services and computation of TCS
93
14
The benefit of the comparison between the tax computed at the amended rate without indexation and the earlier rate with indexation is subject to the prescribed conditions, including acquisition of the property before 23rd July 2024, in the case of a resident individual or HUF. Since the assessee is a resident individual, the acquisition date is essential to determine whether the relevant grandfathering protection is applicable. In the absence of this information, candidates cannot conclusively determine the appropriate tax treatment. Request: Kindly consider this omission and provide appropriate evaluation for alternative answers based on the assumptions adopted by candidates. 4. Question 4(a)(ii) – Sale of Natural Gas by ABC Ltd. Reference: Descriptive Question 4(a)(ii), Page 24. The question states that ABC Ltd., a producer of natural gas, sold natural gas worth ₹26,50,000 to M/s Deep Co., a partnership firm. It also incurred ₹1,70,000 towards freight and separately bifurcated the value of gas and transportation charges in the invoice. Observation: The question does not provide the turnover/gross receipts details of ABC Ltd. or M/s Deep Co. for the immediately preceding financial year. If the question intends to examine the applicability of Section 194Q or Section 206C(1H), the prescribed turnover conditions are material for determining whether the respective provisions apply. Without the relevant turnover details, candidates cannot conclusively establish the applicability of the TDS/TCS provisions or determine the consequent tax deduction/collection liability. Further, the separate disclosure of transportation charges in the invoice makes the determination of the relevant transaction value important. Request: Kindly review the question and consider the missing information while evaluating the answers, including technically justified alternative interpretations. Overall Request In view of the above observations, I sincerely request the Examination Department to: 1. Undertake a detailed question-wise review of the above-mentioned questions. 2. Examine whether the missing factual information has resulted in multiple reasonable interpretations or alternative computations. 3. Ensure that candidates adopting technically correct approaches under the applicable provisions are not unfairly penalised. 4. Consider appropriate bonus marks or compensatory marks wherever the ambiguity or omission has materially affected candidates' ability to arrive at a definitive answer. I fully understand that examinations are intended to assess the conceptual understanding and practical application of taxation provisions. However, it is equally important that questions provide all material facts necessary to arrive at an unambiguous conclusion. I therefore request the Institute to kindly examine these observations in the interest of fairness and consistency in the evaluation process. Thank you for your time and consideration. Yours faithfully, Name: [Candidate's Name] Registration Number: [Registration Number] Roll Number: [Roll Number] Email ID: [Email Address] Mobile Number: [Mobile Number] CA Final Examination – November 2026 Paper 4 – Direct Tax Laws & International Taxation
97
15
To: examfeedback@icai.in Respected Sir/Madam, I wish to respectfully bring to your kind attention certain ambiguities and omissions observed in the CA Final November 2026 examination question paper for Paper 4 – Direct Tax Laws & International Taxation. Upon reviewing the question paper, I have identified certain questions where relevant factual information required for arriving at a definitive tax treatment or computation appears to be missing. These issues may have resulted in multiple interpretations and difficulty in arriving at a unique answer despite candidates having adequate conceptual understanding of the applicable provisions. The observations are detailed below for your kind consideration. 1. Question 1 – Bardhaman Technologies Ltd. – Foreign Exchange Loss on Restatement of Foreign Currency Liability Reference: Descriptive Question 1, Page 16. The question states: "There was an exchange loss of ₹7,30,000 on restatement of foreign currency term liability (principal amount ₹80,00,000), incurred for purchase of plant & machinery, as on 31st March, 2026; company capitalized 60% of this loss to the cost of plant and machinery and debited balance 40% to P&L." Observation: The question does not specify whether the plant and machinery was acquired from outside India or whether the foreign currency liability represents an outstanding amount payable to a foreign supplier or a foreign currency loan obtained for acquiring the machinery. This distinction is material for determining the applicability of Section 43A and the corresponding tax treatment of foreign exchange fluctuations. The tax treatment of exchange differences arising from a foreign currency liability for acquisition of an asset may differ depending upon the nature of the liability and the circumstances of acquisition. In the absence of these facts, candidates may reasonably arrive at different conclusions regarding the allowability of the exchange loss and its adjustment to the actual cost of the asset. Request: Kindly consider this ambiguity and accept alternative technically correct treatments based on reasonable assumptions, wherever supported by the applicable provisions. 2. Question 2(a)(i) – M/s AV & Co. – Payment to Micro Enterprise Reference: Descriptive Question 2(a)(i), Page 18. The question states that an invoice of ₹1,50,000 was issued by M/s RS & Co. on 1st March 2026, with an agreed credit period of 30 days. Payment was subsequently made on 5th April 2026. Observation: Under Section 15 of the MSMED Act, 2006, the prescribed payment period is determined with reference to the date of acceptance or deemed acceptance of goods or services. However, the question provides only the invoice date and the agreed credit period, without specifically mentioning the date of delivery or acceptance of the goods. Since the date of acceptance is relevant for determining the statutory payment deadline and consequently the applicability of Section 43B(h), the absence of this information creates uncertainty in determining the exact due date. Request: Kindly consider the missing factual detail and provide appropriate consideration to alternative interpretations where candidates have applied the relevant statutory provisions correctly. 3. Question 3(b) – Mr. Ishu – Long-Term Capital Gains on Sale of Residential House Reference: Descriptive Question 3(b), Pages 22–23. The question provides the following details regarding the sale of a residential house in Delhi in March 2026: - Long-term capital gains without indexation: ₹40,00,000. - Long-term capital gains with indexation: ₹30,00,000. Observation: The question does not specify the date on which the residential property was originally acquired. This information is material in view of the amended provisions of Section 112 applicable to transfers of land or buildings on or after 23rd July 2024.
120
16
ICAI should also verify the reporting dates, approval dates and transaction dates in the questions to ensure that no contradictory or impossible timeline has been introduced. 10. Request for a fair and uniform compensatory mechanism Apart from the above individual discrepancies, we wish to highlight an important issue concerning the case study-based MCQs. Different candidates may receive different MCQ sequences or different case study question sets. Consequently, the same examination may expose candidates to questions with different levels of complexity, interpretation requirements and computational demands. While different sets may be necessary to maintain examination integrity, it is equally important that all sets are equivalent in difficulty and technical correctness. We therefore request ICAI to: Conduct an independent question-wise technical review of all MCQs and descriptive questions identified in this representation. Compare the different case study-based MCQ sets administered to candidates. Verify that all sets were equivalent in difficulty, complexity and time requirements. Identify questions with missing data, incorrect information, ambiguous wording, incorrect options or multiple technically valid answers. Award full marks for questions found to be technically defective or without a valid answer. Consider suitable compensatory or normalization marks where material differences in difficulty between question sets are established. Ensure that the evaluation process does not penalise candidates for errors or ambiguities attributable to question-setting rather than their knowledge and preparation. Our humble submission CA Final is a critical milestone in the professional journey of every Chartered Accountancy student. Candidates dedicate several years of preparation and considerable personal and financial resources to this examination. A difference of even one or two marks can determine the outcome of an entire examination attempt. We are not seeking any undue advantage or relaxation in academic standards. We are simply requesting that the examination be assessed on the principles of fairness, equality, technical accuracy and consistency. Where a question is defective, ambiguous or technically incorrect, the responsibility of resolving the resulting disadvantage should not rest upon the students. We therefore sincerely request ICAI to acknowledge these observations, conduct an appropriate technical review and grant suitable bonus/compensatory marks to all affected candidates wherever warranted. We also request that the Institute communicate the outcome of its review and the corrective measures adopted. We trust that ICAI will give this representation the serious consideration it deserves in the larger interest of students and the credibility of the CA Final examination system. Thank you. Yours faithfully, Concerned CA Final Students CA Final – November 2026 On behalf of affected candidates
124
17
Any ambiguity regarding whether the company had an enforceable right to defer settlement at the reporting date can result in different classifications. Request: Review the wording and ensure that candidates are not penalised where the facts do not sufficiently establish the intended classification. 5. Missing, incorrect or potentially multiple correct MCQ options Several MCQs require particular scrutiny regarding the correctness and completeness of the available answer options. The coal purchase contract question involving a foreign currency-denominated contract is one such question that should be independently reviewed. ICAI is requested to verify whether: At least one option represents the technically correct answer. More than one option could reasonably be considered correct. The wording of the question is consistent with the applicable Ind AS. No candidate is disadvantaged because the correct answer is absent from the options. Where no correct option is available or multiple answers are technically defensible, the affected candidates should receive appropriate marks. 6. Effective interest rate discrepancy – Convertible preference shares The descriptive question concerning Vindhyachal Refineries Limited specifies an effective interest rate of 16.60%. The calculation and the stated rate should be independently verified against the underlying contractual terms and prescribed calculation methodology. Even a small discrepancy in the effective interest rate can affect the subsequent amortised cost calculation and journal entries throughout the arrangement. Request: Verify the correctness of the stated rate and consider appropriate relief if the rate or underlying data are erroneous. 7. Classification and valuation of land and investment properties The questions concerning Y Limited and Parag Limited require candidates to classify different properties and determine their accounting treatment. In particular, the question concerning Parag Limited's freehold land mentions: Carrying value of ₹10,00,000. Indexed value of ₹16,00,000. Fair value of ₹22,00,000. Application of the revaluation model. No intention to sell the land in the foreseeable future. Land being in excess of the company's requirements. The classification and valuation requirements need to be examined in light of the applicable provisions of Ind AS 16 and Ind AS 40. The distinction between owner-occupied property, property held for future use and investment property must be clearly established before prescribing a particular valuation model. Request: Review the technical consistency of the facts and the accounting treatment expected from candidates. 8. Lease classification under Ind AS 116 The question concerning G Limited's machinery lease asks candidates to classify the lease according to its nature and determine the accounting treatment in the books of G Limited. The question requires clarification because Ind AS 116 prescribes a single lessee accounting model, unlike the previous distinction between operating and finance leases for lessees. If the intention was to test the lessor's classification or another aspect of the lease, the wording should have clearly specified the applicable perspective. Request: Review the framing of the question and consider appropriate relief if candidates were required to apply an obsolete classification framework. 9. Incorrect standard references and reporting-date inconsistencies The questions relating to subsequent events and variable consideration require technical scrutiny. In particular, variable consideration is governed by Ind AS 115, whereas Ind AS 10 deals with events after the reporting period. The question involving conditional customer discounts should be examined to ensure that the applicable standard and reporting-period facts are correctly presented.
122
18
Email Subject Urgent Representation – Technical Errors, Ambiguities and Discrepancies in CA Final Financial Reporting Examination, November 2026 – Request for Bonus/Compensatory Marks To, The President The Secretary The Examination Department The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) Respected Sir/Madam, We wish to formally bring to your attention several serious technical discrepancies, ambiguities and possible errors observed in the CA Final Financial Reporting examination conducted in November 2026. After examining the question paper, we have identified multiple instances where the framing of questions, availability of information, technical references and answer options appear to have created genuine difficulties for candidates. We respectfully submit that these concerns are not merely related to the difficulty of the examination. They relate to the technical validity, clarity and fairness of the questions themselves. The following observations are submitted for your consideration. 1. Ambiguity regarding functional currency – Foreign subsidiary and goodwill MCQ The question concerning NG Ltd. and SG Inc. (the foreign subsidiary) asks candidates to calculate goodwill on acquisition. The question mentions the functional currency of the foreign entity as US Dollars. However, the reference to the entity and the intended currency conversion basis requires clarification, particularly concerning the distinction between the parent and subsidiary. The ambiguity may lead to different interpretations and materially different answers, including alternative calculations of USD 3 million and USD 6 million. A candidate should not be required to guess the intended interpretation of an accounting question. Request: Review the question and award appropriate bonus marks if more than one technically defensible interpretation exists. 2. Arbitrary Boolean coding – Automated process MCQ The question concerning the automated process for identifying performance obligations asks candidates to consider Boolean values (0 or 1) and the coding of Yes/No responses. The question effectively relies on a particular coding convention illustrated in an example rather than testing a clearly established accounting principle. The problem is particularly concerning where the question tests the direction of coding, namely whether 0 represents Yes or No and whether 1 represents Yes or No. Candidates should be assessed on their understanding and application of accounting concepts rather than an arbitrary coding convention that may not be an established accounting requirement. Request: Review the question and consider bonus marks if the intended coding convention was not sufficiently established in the question or prescribed learning material. 3. Inconsistency in interest rates – Loan notes MCQ The question concerning K Ltd. and loan notes describes the instrument as 1% loan notes while also referring to interest payable at 4% of the face value. The presence of two different interest rates in the same question creates uncertainty regarding the actual contractual interest rate and the calculation of the financial liability. Candidates may reasonably interpret the information differently, affecting the effective interest calculation and initial measurement. Request: Verify the intended contractual interest rate and consider the question defective if the discrepancy materially affects the answer. 4. Classification of loan liability – Covenant breach MCQ The question concerning Diversified Limited's long-term bank loan involves a breach of financial covenants and subsequent negotiations with the bank. The classification of the liability requires careful consideration of the conditions existing at the reporting date and the timing and legal effect of the subsequent agreement.
190
19
📱Let's connect on LinkedIn. https://www.linkedin.com/in/jigarjkadiya
222
20
Upgrade Your CA Prep! Join the Jan 2027 Prime Batch Today 📚 Experts will help you prepare for the ICAI Sept/Nov Examination
Upgrade Your CA Prep! Join the Jan 2027 Prime Batch Today 📚 Experts will help you prepare for the ICAI Sept/Nov Examination 2026 ✅ Application-based Questions ✅ Notes + Doubt solving + Mentoring + Guidance Videos ✅ Suggested Answers + Toppers Sheets for comparison ✅ Study Planners + Imp Q’s + Imp MCQs & Case Study MCQs ✅ 17+ unique techniques to enhance performance ✅ Systematic, effective revision road map Coupon Code - CARESULT Register: https://www.catestseries.org/register.php ▶️ WhatsApp: 78886-34515 | CAtestSeries.org
245